|
Original Plan (my data) |
Revised Plan (Mr.
Cafiero’s plan) |
| Most interesting was a 1935 proposal
(updated in 1946) by L. Alfred Jenny, a consulting engineer who began his
career on the Grand Central Terminal project. The plan consisted of a modern
electrified railroad connecting the various railroads in New Jersey and
bringing these lines into a compact union passenger terminal in
mid-Manhattan. |
This proposal is an adaptation on the
work of Col. Alfred Jenny. Col. Jenny
who was involved in the building of Grand Central Terminal developed his
concept during the 1910-1950 period. It is to be noted that the accommodation
of three tracks, from West of the Hudson, was included in the original
planning of Grand Central Terminal. Modifications to the original plan
proposed by Col. Jenny have been made necessary by the UPTOWN CREEP of the
Midtown Central Business District. |
| The first link in New Jersey, outside of
the tunnel portal at Bergen, would have been at New Durham, serving the
Northern Railroad of New Jersey (Erie), the West Shore, and the New York,
Susquehanna & Western. The estimated number of commuters was 4.2 million
annually as well as 1.5 million other passengers. |
New Starts, Restore Service on West Shore and NYS&W in Bergen,
Passaic and Rockland Counties. Northern Branch light rail now with possible
conversion to heavy rail after 63rd Street tunnel is completed. |
| Another link would have been a new
railroad across the Hackensack Meadows to Kingsland on the DL&W Boonton
Branch. It would also have connected with the Erie main line at Meadows. It
was estimated 4.2 million commuters and 1.2 million others would use this
connection each year. |
Bergen Direct Connector to New Tunnel& Corridor for present
and new rail services from Bergen & Passaic. |
| The final link would have gone south
across the Hackensack Meadows to a point southeast of Newark. It would have
connected the Newark branch of the Erie, the DL&W main line, the B&O,
Lehigh Valley and Central RR of New Jersey. This connection would have drawn
9.6 million annual commuters and 7.7 million others. A transfer station at
North Bergen would have allowed superior connections between Northern New
Jersey and Southern New Jersey. Included in the plan was electrification of
existing railroads in New Jersey. For instance, the West Shore would have
been initially electrified to Dumont; the Erie main line to Paterson; and the
NYS&W to Hawthorne. |
|
| The 10.4 million "other"
passengers planned for were the long haul types who began disappearing after
1946. Even included here were the trickle of passengers that the Ontario
& Western still carried to the Catskills. The 18 million commuters would
be a low estimate for today. |
Downtown Jersey City Tunnel to Newark Airport to connect with the
NE Corridor Line. |
| The terminal in Manhattan was to have
been bounded by 49th Street, 50th Street, 6th Avenue and 7th
Avenue. This site is now part of Rockefeller Center (Exxon Building). At the
time of this proposal, that area was somewhat less developed and thus a
bargain. The terminal was designed to be underground on two levels. Incoming
trains would unload on the lower level, then proceed over loop tracks to the
upper level for departure. Each level was to have had 14 tracks with 7
platforms long enough to hold from 10 to 14 cars. By combining shorter trains
on the New Jersey side in order to reduce the number of trains, two one-track
tunnels were anticipated. Escalators and stairways would bring passengers up
to a concourse. Short connections would have been provided to 6th Avenue, 7th
Avenue and Broadway subways. It was planned to bring short freights through
the tunnels during off-peak hours and connect with the New York Central West
Side Freight Line. |
A new tunnel would cross the Hudson River in
the neighborhood of 63rd Street to connect in a Wye with the Spine
Line as well as with LIRR coming from the east through the East River 63rd
Street Tunnel. This would provide
direct access to GCT and Lincoln Center for both the LIRR and NJ Transit. Part of this Phase would be a connection
with the West Side Line to provide access to the rail Yards north of 125th
Street to provide midday storage for NJ Transit, LIRR and Metro North. Trains
would come from NJ stop at Lincoln Center and continue to GCT. Trains from Queens would also Terminate at
GCT. Empty equipment would lay over
in the 125 Street yards. |
| A future add-on would have been a subway
connection to Grand Central Terminal then to Fifth Avenue and downtown to the
Battery. It could even have been extended under the Hudson River to Jersey
City. A station at 33rd Street would have given direct connection to Long
Island trains. |
Continue the Spine Line with trains stopping
at new platforms beneath the Lower Level of GCT to another Wye at 33rd
Street. LIRR trains could return to
Queens while NJT trains could return to NJ via Penn Station. Reverse direction travel would also apply
for both lines. Same as Phase I, but some trains would continue in the deep
tunnel to the 33Rd Street tunnels. NJ Transit trains would bear right returning to NJ via Penn
Station. LIRR trains could bear left to return to Long Island City or
terminate at Penn Station. |
|
Phase
III Complete the Spine Line downtown to the
Financial Center and run into two underwater tunnels, one to connect with NJ
Transit in Hoboken, and the other to the LIRR at Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn.
Adds to Phase II the options of continuing downtown to the Financial District
with NJ Transit returning via Hoboken and LIRR returning via Brooklyn. |
|
Phase
IIIB. If
a four way interchange is built at 33rd Street, trains from Penn
Station and Long Island City could also reach the Spine Line at 33rd
Street and continue Downtown to the Financial Center tunnels. |
|
Phases
II, III & IIIB would also accommodate trains
in the opposite directions and would be built to accommodate all three lines
in any direction including running trains from New Jersey to Long Island and
Westchester. Trains from the West
Shore and all other rail lines coming from Bergen and Rockland Counties would
have direct access to New York City and possibly Newark. |
| The 1946 cost was projected at
$117,840,000 to be financed by a combination of Public Authority, the
railroads, and the public. Railroads had always paid a premium to enter New
York. When the B&O ran passenger trains into Penn Station, it paid
$720,000 per year. By 1946, the B&O was using busses which cost almost as
much. |
No
clue! |